您好,欢迎来到皮书数据库! 登录|注册
您现在所在的位置:首页  > 中国经济发展数据库
更多>> 课题组动态
更多>> 专题子库
旅游专题库
    皮书数据库旅游专题根据旅游专业院校、高校旅游专业、旅游专业... 详情>>
更多>> 皮书作者
蔡 昉
    1956年9月生于北京。现任中国社会科学院副院长、党组成员,曾任中国社会科学院人口与劳动经济研究所所长,博士生导师,研... 详情>>
李培林
    男,山东济南人。博士,研究员,中国社会科学院副院长,中国社会学会副会长,中国社会科学院社会学研究所副所长。《社会... 详情>>
李 扬
    1951年9月出生,籍贯安徽,1981年、1984年、1989年分别于安徽大学、复旦大学、中国人民大学获经济学学士、硕士、博士学位... 详情>>

    皮书评价及内容质量提升对策研究——皮书内容评价报告(2019)

    摘要

    皮书内容评价是对皮书的内容质量进行考察,皮书内容评价指标体系,既包括研究主题的价值与意义、科学性、前沿性、规范性、时效性、应用性等主观性指标,实证性、出版时间、书稿要件等客观性指标,又根据皮书的特点和要求设置了加分项和减分项。报告分析了2014~2018年皮书内容评价的总体情况、各指标的得分率,特别是前100名皮书的类别分布、研创机构分布、主题分布等。通过皮书评价,发现皮书内容质量存在以下几个问题:数据再加工不足;报告名、摘要、关键词撰写不规范;内容框架逻辑性不强;出版时间不规律,数据时间表述不清;内容重复率较高。未来皮书评价和研创应设置针对不同类别皮书的内容评价指标体系;吸纳更多相关领域的评审专家,进一步完善同行评审制度;扩大《皮书手册:写作、编辑出版与评价指南》的使用范围;严格执行准入退出机制;探索皮书选题指导制度。

    <<
    >>

    Abstract

    Pishu publications are subject to evaluation of the merit of their contents. A Pishu evaluation index system in working order is now in place that allows evaluators to rate individual Pishu publication in the following respects:the significance of the subject matter,its scientific import,impact of the research on the wider academic community,how appropriately timed its publication was and its practical implications. These are in addition to basic requirements included in any industry guidelines governing the publication of research reports such as the yearbooks. Items have also been identified that correspond to indicators on which points can be either added or deducted. This chapter is a meta-analysis of Pishu evaluation reports compiled in 2014~2018. On the basis of how the different Pishu titles were graded in these reports,the 100 top-ranked Pishus were identified,and analyzed in terms of the topics they cover and the research teams responsible for them. The meta-analysis shows that many Pishu publications fall short with respect to statistical analysis,consistency in style,structural soundness,timing regularity,and content originality. Improving Pishu evaluation calls for more rigorous peer review,subject area-specific evaluation,stronger enforcement of Pishu style guide,and publication-worthiness requirements.

    <<
    >>
    作者简介
    丁阿丽:丁阿丽,社会科学文献出版社皮书研究院院长助理,成果评价中心主任,研究方向为社会学。
    <<
    >>
    相关报告